Input Methods in XR: Gloves

Haptic gloves are used to directly manipulate digital objects, and provide feedback similar to that of real-world objects. The gloves currently on the market are used on the higher-end 6-DoF headsets. They have a variety of capabilities, so it’s important to know ahead of time which features you need your gloves to have to enhance your experience.

There are two main types of haptic feedback available. The ideal gloves will give you both.

Force

Force feedback provides resistance, which means when you touch an object or try to squeeze it, resistance will stop your fingers from moving further. This gives the sense of a solid object in physical space.

Tactile

Tactile feedback gives the sense of touch, like a butterfly landing on your finger or the feeling of different textures on your skin.

Pros

You get better hand and finger tracking in virtual space.
It’s a more natural interaction.
It frees your hands from the use of controllers.
Direct manipulation means no learning curve since you’re interacting the way you would in real life.
Depending on the quality of the gloves, it can feel like you’re interacting with real, physical objects.
Your hands don’t have to be within line of sight of cameras on your headset to be tracked like they do with camera-based hand tracking.

Cons

The gloves can get sweaty. Since they’re sensitive and need to be handled with care, it can be tricky to clean them.
The sizing of gloves can be an issue for large or small hands. You may need multiple sizes. The ones that are one-size-fits-all won’t support larger or smaller hands.
The more advanced gloves are cumbersome and heavy, increasing risk of fatigue for longer or extended interactions.
They can be expensive.
They can be sensitive and buggy.

TL;DR Do’s and Don’ts

Do

For heavier gloves, keep the interactions short and simple.
Ensure longer duration interactions are within the participant’s physical comfort zone.
Follow physical ergonomic design standards.
If using gestures with the gloves, use tooltips and memory cues to remind people how to use any formed gestures.
Minimize the amount of formed gestures used or required in your experiences.

Don’t

Don’t make gloves the primary input method for your experience unless there’s a very good reason. They should be supplemental to enhance the experience for those who have access to them.
Don’t design interactions that require arms being raised for extended periods of time.
If using gestures with the gloves, don’t use overly-complicated gestures that people will have to memorize.

Best used

In my opinion, these are not yet ready for mass adoption due to cost, sizing, and technology limitations. However, there are very good use cases for them now in Enterprise, Manufacturing, Safety, and Medical industries. If you just need direct manipulation and the headset supports it, hand tracking alone may suffice unless you need the tactile or force feedback provided by gloves.

Example cases for immediate use would be for training, virtual therapies or telerobotics solutions.

Always double check the specs for the gloves to make sure they’ll work with your desired headset.

Learn more

Physical Factors: Fatigue in XR
HaptX Telerobotics
Teslasuit VR Gloves
Xsens Gloves by Manus
Dexmo Gloves by DextaRobotics
SenseGlove Nova
The VR Book by Jason Jerald PhD, Input Devices: Hand-Word Devices, pg 312, 316-317, 362

If you enjoy these articles, consider supporting me on Patreon.

I’m an Immersive Tech UX Design Professional with over 22 years of experience designing for kiosks, websites, mobile apps and desktop software for many well-known and not-so-well-known companies.

I’m not speaking on behalf of or representing any company. These are my personal thoughts, experiences and opinions.